I had a few small 1" X 2" tiles to replace in a bathroom once.
My kids play with a plastic modeling clay that gets baked in the oven to set. It can be purchased at AC Moore and similar craft stores.
I experimented til I mixed the colors to the right shade, cut and shaped the tiles, then baked them to harden. After that I sprayed them with a clear enamel.
WORKED GREAT! NO ONE CAN TELL THE DIFFERENCE!
© 2017 Renovate Your World LLC