Looks like the Hunter may be the way to go. I checked the Grainger catalog here at work. The White-Rodgers 1F90-371 lists at $268.00 but Grainger sells for $125.50. Good discount but still pricey. This model was highly recommended on an HVAC forum I visit from time to time.
The Honeywells don't seem to be as reliable...according to what I read on the HVAC forum.
I think I'll stop by Payless and check out the Hunter. Good price and reliable.