Aaron, I added onto my house in '98 and my contractor, an Hispanic man who employed his entire family in the business, hired a masonry contractor who was able to provide a very close match, so close that most who see the home for the first time cannot tell the new 600 sq ft addition is new. The original home was constructed circa 1972. We had the entire south (front) of the house painted to match the new stucco. I will say that the painting of the remainder of the existing frontage really sucked up the paint. I would think that any good stucco subcontractor could provide a good match. I could attach some photos if you wish. good luck with the project. Pat.