I've been trying to restore my bathroom to it's 1927 style. We've gotten the new tile and adhesive off and found remarkabley preserved 3"x6" subway tiles underneath. We need to replace a few and have had NO luck in finding a match at several stores here in Chicago. As a last resort I've decided to remove the top row of tile, which I can replace with a different color without destroying the overall effect. However, I wanted to know if anyone else ever had this problem and how they dealt with it.
Please don't tell me to gut a re-tile the whole thing.