The key is in your policy!
If they are suposed to make it right, then they need to strip the house and do it over if they can't match the siding.
Painting is NOT an option.
I'm sure they would not accept "not quite" the amount of your premium, so why should you accept, not quite" having your house look right?
Stand your ground and keep asking to speek to someone above anyone that tells you otherwise.
If you are going through an agency and they are not helping, demand that they do something.
You may have to ask to go to the insurance company direct.
The bottom line is fight.
© 2016 Renovate Your World LLC