On The Level - The Home Improvement Blog
About our bloggers
Contact our bloggers

That tree could grow up to be an eco-friendly boon or the cause of an ugly neighborhood dispute.

Tree Dispute Raises Tough Questions

Most of us know that trees are an effective, environment-friendly way to shade your home and save on air conditioning costs in the summer months. But when do trees in your yard become an impediment to your neighbors?

London's Guardian tackled that issue on Monday in this tale of dysfunctional suburbia across the pond. Plymouth resident David Alvand's neighbors have launched a formal complaint against his 16 10-meter-tall leyland cyprus trees, whose branches overhang the street and the neighbors' roofs, blocking out sunlight, and allegedly making the block look bad.

This is no isolated incident. The leyland cyprus trees, commonly known as leylandii, grow extremely quickly, causing countless suburban disputes across England and Wales as neighbors complain about these trees infringing on their territory. These conflicts even led to a "high hedges" section in the UK's Anti-Social Behaviour Act of 2003, which allowed homeowners to take their neighbors to legal task because of unsightly hedges. Indeed, Alvand's neighbors are using this clause to take him to court.

In Treehugger.com's article about this conflict, the blogger suggested that Alvand's neighbors leave him alone and plant some trees of their own. A valid opinion, but I'm inclined to disagree. I have no problem with the trees if they stay in their owners' yards, but once they start casting shadows on other peoples' property, then it becomes a problem. They even impede neighbors from engaging in other eco-friendly activities: in this clash over the same issue in Norfolk in 2008, an affected woman said that she was overjoyed that the trees had been removed because it meant that she once again had access to enough sunlight to grow vegetables in her backyard.

Tell us what you think. Should the neighbors stop sticking their noses in Alvand's business and think about the positive effects of the trees? Or do they have a legitimate complaint?


Login or Register to Comment
Title/Content Author


09/09/2010 11:08 AM hollywoodhunk2

I feel that a person should have as many trees on their land as they want as long as the limbs or shadows do not cross the line then that infringes on other people rights.

Member Since

Total Contributions

Login or Register to Comment

Air space

09/09/2010 04:40 PM Handyman

You own your air space. You can cut the limbs that extend into your yard.

You also have the right to ask your neighbor to maintain their trees for safety issues.

There are also millions of HOAs in this country that tell you what you can do in your yard.

If you are not in an HOA many municipalities have maintenance requirements for yards.

However cutting healthy trees because they shade your neighbors yard is a new one on me.


Member Since

Total Contributions

Login or Register to Comment
  Login or Register to Comm ent

About  | FAQ  | Contact  | Sitemap  | Privacy Policy  | Terms of Use  | Help

© 2017 Renovate Your World LLC